Which should I choose

Ok.. Tonight I have been planning to spend the night with a guy who I have only met once (which sounds stupid I know)but he seems really nice. He is kinda shady and I dont really like that in a guy.. Well just a minute ago, another guy who I have know for a while asked me to go ice skating with him and his friends tonight. I told him I have plans but I really want to go. I really do want to go but how do I get out of the spending the night ordeal in a nice way??????? HELP

You've only met this guy once, and for all you know, he can be dangerous when it's just the two of you. The best choice is to not go with any of em. Make it fair. Find something else to do. :)