Dating help

I'm a girl. 16 soon. I used to go to school with this guy. I liked him, literally, since the first time I saw him. And he doesn't exactly look like an underwear model lol, but there was just this click. Funny thing is he told me he likes me, but I kinda rejected him. Thing is I'm trying to be a good, happy, Christian girl, and he's a stoner and not on a good path and sometimes I feel like he's condescending, a little insensitive, but I'm crazy about him! I moved, haven't seen him in two years, unfriended him months ago, we've seen other people, but I can't get him out of my brain, and I don't want to as much as I think I should. I know he still liked me before i made a new fb and didn't accept his request.What should I do? Any thoughts on the the situation? Anything at all would be great.

You need to figure out what draws him to you, you said his attitude and choices aren't amazing, so what makes him so special? Why is he so different from other guys you have dated.